Reviews

Based on 98 reviews
84%
(82)
15%
(15)
1%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
j
Diavola
jim mannix
very good crust

It was a day late but turned out very good. The two I put into the freezer, can I still cook at 500 ?

Wonderful

We loved this Sausage pizza. Very fresh. Love, love, love the crust!!!!!

Wanted to try NY Pizza in Omaha - Best Sausage Pizza I have ever had

The sausage flavor is mild, this pizza doesn't have red sauce, but does have olive oil. The fresh mozzarella is so amazing. The pizza came frozen in a foil pack, in just 2 days. I did keep in the freezer for several days before eating. Tossed in the oven for 5-7 min at 500. I wasn't sure about putting it on a pan, but did, per the instructions. The crust came out so good, I can't way to try it fresh out of the oven, hoping to catch NY Giants game this fall. #GoGiants

Outstanding

The four cheese pizza was outstanding and cooked up with a nice crisp crust. The cheese could have been pushed in little further out to the edge.

J
Diavola
James Moran
Pizza

Best frozen pizza I have ever tried!!! Absolutely recommend!

Pistacchio e Salciccia (Sausage)

Bought these for my husband after watching Diners, Drive-ins and Dives, and he was so anxious for them to come. They did not disappoint! He ate a whole one in one sitting, and vowed not to share the remaining two with anyone! He savored every morsel, and will order again!

Excellent!!!

If I could give the Pistachio e Salciccia more than 5 stars, I would. The toppings marry so well together and all of the ingredients tasted fresh. I cooked this on my pizza stone at 500 for about 8 minutes from partially frozen. Perfection!! I will definitely order this again, probably in multiples.

Delicious!

Surprised my family with NY Pizza. Everyone raved about it!
A little pricey to send across country-but well worth it 😃

Not Bad At All

A little greasy, but I would definately order again. Thanks!

Awesome!!

This pizza was so good!! Baked it as soon as it arrived!!

Really good…

Enjoyed this pizza. Well made — good ingredients.

Awesome pizza flavor, and the crust is truly in a class all of its own.

Worst Experience Ever

First time customer, ordered 10 pizza's. They all arrived warm (not even the slightest bit cool). All the food is spoiled. Contacted Keste and they agreed that the product should not have arrived in that condition. They promised me they would prepare a replacement order for the 10 pizza's I ordered and make sure that it was either packed properly with enough ice to go from the East Coast to the West Coast and get here sooner.
WELL IT'S BEEN DAYS SINCE THAT PROMISE AND NO CONTACT FROM KESTE REGARDING MY REPLACEMENT ORDER BEING FILLED AND SHIPPED.
So, can't even comment on whether the pizza's are good or not as the ones I received were not edible.

R
Margherita
Randy P
MargheritaPizza

Ordering process: Easy.
Shipping: Quick, arrived well frozen, and not broken. There is enough dry ice for 2-3 shipping. Might explore this option to reduce cost to customer.
Instructions: Generally good, should state to thaw the pizza prior to cooking for those who don't know.
Taste: Really good. Dough is tasty, great chew. Sauce and cheese very good. I will say that it was not as good reheated.
Order again: Yes.

Pistacchio e Salciccia (Sausage)

Delicious pizza, would order again. I would like to try this sausage pizza with red sauce.

The best

Absolutely the best lightest pizza I have ate

Yum!

Brought me back to Napoli!

M
Diavola
Michael Keleher
Wanted to try NY Pizza in Omaha

After seeing you on Triple D on food network, had to give the online order and shipping a try. The Diavola was my favorite, peperoni is spicy, so fair warning. UPS did mess up our first shipment, but was replaced promptly. We held in the freezer for 3 days, then cooked per instructions. Definitely a quality pizza, crust was amazing, thin and crunchy. We did enjoy our pizza, but there is nothing like fresh pizza out of the oven. When we are in NY this fall for the Giants game, we definitely will make a point to try it fresh!

D
Diavola
Darrell Redleaf-Fielder
BEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD

Keste pizzas are the best in the world. Period. I was hesitant ordering to be delivered from NY (I live in LA) They arrived and we baked 2 immediately, they were as good as if I was eating at the restaurant in NYC! Imagine all the money I will save not flying to NYC to have my favorite pizza in the world!
ITS NOW A REALITY! Order them ASAP! Also I ordered 6 of them, and kept them frozen until I was ready to eat them, you have to take them out of the freezer, DO NOT OPEN, allow the pizza to thaw, room temp for about an hour before baking at 500 degrees for 4-5 mins, keep an eye on them tho, 4.5 mins in perfect!!! MANJA and ENJOY!!!

D
Margherita
Dianne Thorington
Yummy!

Delicious pizza. The crust was amazing. Who knew you could get pizza this good through the mail?

The best pizza ever!

Honestly I have never had a pizza this good. All of the topping came together to make this a delicious pizza. And the crust was outstanding. Definitely ordering it again!

Truly amazing

My order was shipped to Oregon it arrived not frozen but we cooked it and ate it and it was the BEST pizza we have had in years it was amazing and we all agreed we will be ordering again that crust is the best that sauce is so good truly NY Times vote as best pizza in NY is right

J
Margherita
Jeffrey Klein
Delicious

Heated up easily and tasted delicious. Froze another one and it tasted great too but not quite as good as the one out of the box. Will order more.

A
Margherita
Amy Rodriguez
Better than pizza in California

Pizza is terrible on the west coast so I was thrilled to be able to get some shipped from NY. The only complaint would be nothing was labeled (and some pizzas look alike) and the directions were a bit lacking. Kinda expensive but it really is delicious.

A
Diavola
Amy Rodriguez
Yum!

The cheese, the sauce, the meat…. Soooo good. Already ordered more