Reviews

Based on 1089 reviews
82%
(898)
6%
(67)
3%
(33)
3%
(36)
5%
(55)
J
Diavola - Gluten Free
Jacqueline in Utah
Heavenly GF Pizza!

Since moving from NYC area, we have missed Keste pizza... We are thrilled to be able to order amazing pizza to our new home in Utah. This pizza is amazing... my husband is not GF and he also enjoys the gluten free pizza from Keste.

B
Campania
Barbara Jackson

My husband and I truly love the lasagna. We haven’t tried the pizza or the cake yet, but I’m sure it’s excellent. We will be ordering again. Thank you.

G
Padrino
Gordon Holiday
2nd pizza from Keste

Great ingredients. Toothy crust. Great sauce. Once again I found I had to double the cooking time in order for the center to be done. Unfortunately this also makes the edge of the crust a bit too crunchy.

G
Margherita
Gordon Holiday
My first pizza from Keste

An excellent pizza with great ingredients and awesome crust.
My only caution is that the cooking instructions recommend a baking time that’s about half what it needs to be. The recommended 3.5-5 minutes resulted in a pizza not done in the middle. I doubled the time and ended up with a great pizza. My oven temp is extremely accurate so I feel like the instructions should be modified.

Enjoyed the GF margherita

Nice gf crust with bubbles. Lots of cheese and fresh basil. Reheated up nicely. Next time I will preheat the pan or use a pizza stone to encourage a crispier texture. That would perfect the delicious chewy crust with a crispy bottom. I think the cheese just made it a softer bottom but wouldn’t want less cheese so I will improvise next time.

Terrific GF!

Really enjoyed this pepperoni GF pizza. Great dough quality and even though it was shipped and reheated it still was tasty and crispy. Wish that it was feasible to order more often but at the price and shipping likely can only do that occasionally. Happy to have NYC pizza.🍕

Yummy

Sausage and mushroom I thought was yummy! Crust was good, plenty of cheese and plenty of sausage. I gave 2 of 3 of my pizza’s as gift. One of the best gluten-free pizzas, I’ve had look forward to trying three more. Happy Holidays

Pastiera Napolitana

This dessert should either be packaged in a smaller container or not offered at all for mail order. Ours was received broken up, likely because of movement in the larger container during transit. In hindsight we would’ve been better off ordering an extra pizza, which is fantastic.

gluten free crust

These are excellent gluten free crust. I just got the plain gluten free crust and load them up!!!

Mailing address wrong

You delivered to my home address not to the address I put in for delivery.

A
Margherita
Anonymous
Amazing

Arrives on time and very fresh. Great pizza👍

T
Diavola
Timothy Keough
Loved this spicy favorite

Crisp crust and a bit more spicy than a normal pepperoni pie, this is my new go to.

The magic of a Maritozzo

The maritozzo at Keste is a must-try! With its soft, fluffy dough and rich, velvety whipped cream, every bite is pure bliss. Perfectly sweet and irresistibly fresh, it’s the ultimate treat you won’t want to miss. Stop by and taste the magic for yourself!

D
Margherita
David Nguyen
Shipment late, food warm, not happy.

The shipment came late due to a shipping error and without notification or tracking. I got to the package a day late, and the pizzas were warm. The pizzas look so good with the char on the undercarriage and everything... but I can't take a chance eating it. Unfortunately, I regret buying the 6-pizza package.

R
Pizza Romana Margherita
Rob Gluckman, Esq.
Shouldn't be called a pi,za

I've lived in South ew York and had pizza in Napoli and Sicily. I have no idea what this is. Cheese and sauce flavorless, crust like it's out of a nature foods store, I could go on. Threw out I my $200 order it was that bad.

L
Davide
Linda Naughton

To expensive for a small dry pizza

AWESOME!!!
Delicious

Not as good as the others

Sadly, this flavor is my least favorite. It really didn’t taste like Cacio e Pepe. It tasted just like plain white pizza, and the crust was very tough. I like their other pizzas tho!

C
Sabrina
Christopher Moore

Excellent, will buy again!

Great Crust for GF

Baked for 5 minutes, added a layer of marinara sauce sprinkled with pecorino, baked 5 more minutes. Best GF pizza I’ve ever had.

S
Vegana - Gluten Free
Susan Robintino
GLUTEN AND DAIRY FREE

Absolutely the BEST pizza that is gluten and dairy free!!!! You have made my daughter so happy to enjoy pizza again!!! Your delivery across the country is seamless. This is the third time I have ordered from you. Thank you!!!

H
Margherita
Humberto Rivas

The crust was good, although towards the center it became so thin that after reheating it didn’t support the ingredients. The flavor was not better than most frozen pizzas. Disappointed

H
Pizza Romana Margherita
Humberto Rivas

The crust was ok, the rest of the pizza tasted like any other frozen pizza. Very dissapointed

S
Margherita
Sirio Calogero
Best pizza by mail

Soft dough, tasty ingredients on top, salted to perfection. All you need is a house oven and 4.5 minutes to bake.

r
Mushrooms and Sausage
richard rollins
pizza delivery policy

Keste Pizza:

While I love your pizza's and I have been a customer quite some time now, I just can't let an issue I had with my last order go by without saying something.
Apparently, my order was dropped off yesterday (Wednesday) around 11am and I was never notified by Fed Ex or Keste Pizza that my order had been delivered. My order just sat on floor in my building's storage over night because it was not marked perishables, so my building concierge nor fed ex knew to put it in our delivery refrigerator. When I opened the box this morning, some of the ice packages were melted and the top of the pizzas and my Cannelloni were not chilled. This has me concerned if the order is still edible or not?

I have discussed this issue about putting "perishable" on the box before, and you did it on one order. But since then, you have not.

Rich