Reviews

Based on 1116 reviews
82%
(912)
6%
(68)
3%
(36)
4%
(40)
5%
(60)
V
Macellaio
Vincent Collins
Macellaio pizza

The macellaio and Margherita pizza’s were great! I miss coming to your location in NYC ! I originally found your Bleeker Street location pre-Covid. Probably the best pizza I’ve had ever! Due to congestion pricing I won’t be coming to your Gold/Fulton Street location! Which I miss !

Ordered a few varieties of pizza!

Have only made this one so far and it was amazing!! Will definitely order again! The packaging and reusable dry ice was an added bonus! Can’t wait to review the rest! Shipping was also great!

G
Padrino
Gayla Self

Love these pizzas

G
Macellaio
Gayla Self

These are all great pizzas!

G
Sabrina
Gayla Self

Love these!

M
Cacio e Pepe
Martin Fisher
Great pizza

My wife and I purchased three pizzas and the first we enjoyed was the cacio e Pepe. It was amazing. The only criticism we could offer is the pizzas did not arrive completely frozen.

Great pizza!

One of the best gluten free pizzas I have ever had!

G
Mushrooms and Sausage
Gordon Holiday
Excellent pizza

This is one of the better pizzas I’ve had from Keste. Great flavors. Great crust.

Gluten Free pizza was amazing!!

N
Mushrooms and Sausage
Neil Castaldi

I love it!!

DELICIOUS GF PIZZA

I ordered the Marguerita GF pizza on a Wednesday, received on Friday. They come packaged perfectly on ice. I put mine in freezer and cooked on a pizza stone right from freezer. I was amazed at how delicious this pizza is and the ingredients are high quality. Don’t hesitate to buy this pizza, it has exceeded my expectations.

C
Macellaio
Carolyn Morningstar
Good

Good pizza, but overpriced.

Very little cheese

These pizzas are disappointing. The Quattro Formaggi had very little cheese with mild flavors. Tasteless.

L
Davide
Leon Chirino
Tasteless and burnt truffle

These pizzas in general are very disappointing. They are tasteless and the Davide had the truffle burnt.

Amazing flavor and the crust is incredible!!! Will definitely order again!

Mostly good. The gluten free crust was very good, which is a hurdle that’s hard for most to manage. The topping however was pretty spartan and a bit of a disappointment

So close to being really good.

The GF crust was pretty darn good. That’s rarely the case for GF. The cheese topping was pretty spartan. I had to doctor the heck out of it to have something besides crust to eat.

N
Margherita
Norman Reuther
Fantastic

Wow! I never would have believed that precooked pizza from New York could be this good. I will definitely be ordering again after my four pizza order has been eaten. That won’t be long!

Great crust

The crust was spongy and nicely chewy on the edge. Nice flavor too. The cheese and sauce were good but could’ve been better.

Crust is ok

Toppings very sparse

Good crust

Ok - toppings are sparse- mostly crust

Too much crust

Too much bread

J
Diavola - Gluten Free
Jacqueline in Utah
Heavenly GF Pizza!

Since moving from NYC area, we have missed Keste pizza... We are thrilled to be able to order amazing pizza to our new home in Utah. This pizza is amazing... my husband is not GF and he also enjoys the gluten free pizza from Keste.

It was ok

I was upset Talia Napoli was stopping pizza purchases so I was happy to find Keste. Unfortunately I didn’t care for it. Ingredients were less quality especially the cheese! Dough didn’t look good either. Won’t purchase again. Cheap looking and taste compared to Talia. Sorry but it’s my honest opinion.

a
Marinara
anthony catalano
We did not like it at all giving it a two is being generous! Nowhere near some of the pizzas we h...

Marinara